Denominational Affiliation 2023

The Way Forward

But if serving the Lord seems undesirable to you, then choose for yourselves this day whom you will serve, whether the gods your ancestors served beyond the Euphrates, or the gods of the Amorites, in whose land you are living. But as for me and my household, we will serve the Lord.” Joshua 24:15


What: a called Church Conference for voting on possible disaffiliation from the United Methodist Church

Why: for reasons of conscience related to human sexuality (particularly same-sex marriage and ordination of self-avowed practicing homosexuals), as well as serious concerns for protecting orthodox doctrine

When: Sunday, February 19, 2023, 4:00 pm

Who: Our District Superintendent, Greg Hackett, will preside. All full members of Northwest Hills UMC have voice and vote. The Annual Conference rules that voting will be in-person only (no absentee or mail-in), and by secret ballot. Only full members of Northwest Hills will be admitted to the meeting. Please bring photo ID, so it can be checked against the membership roster.

A vote of over 2/3 is required to disaffiliate from the UMC. Vote proportions are calculated only with regard to the number of people voting, not the full membership of the church. Abstentions are not part of the calculation, but are treated as a “non-vote.”

If the vote is over 2/3 to disaffiliate, we will then take a vote regarding our future affiliation with another denomination. This vote, too, will be by members only and by secret ballot. A majority vote will be sufficient for choosing a new denominational affiliation.

A meeting to learn about the different Wesleyan denominations will be held Wednesday, February 8 at 7 pm in the Sanctuary to hear and ask questions.

You may download the information here:

Why we are here:

On Monday, July 25, 2022 the Administrative Council of Northwest Hills UMC voted to call the congregation to a 6-month period of prayerful discernment regarding our future relationship to the United Methodist Church.


Background: Since its founding in 1968 the United Methodist Church has had an ongoing debate over homosexual sex, particularly the performance of same-sex weddings and the ordination of self-avowed practicing homosexuals. The General Conference (the governing body of the denomination) has, by majority vote, addressed these issues every four years, each time reaffirming a conservative or traditionalist stance, expressing the grace of God toward all people but prohibiting either practice.


In recent years, increasing numbers of pastors who disagree with the majority vote of the General Conference have intentionally acted in disobedience to the rules of the UMC. More recently, bishops and entire Annual Conferences that disagree have refused to enforce the rules of the UMC. These progressive pastors and bishops say they are pursuing justice and obeying a higher law. Conservatives say they are breaking their ordination and/or consecration vows and, more important, as disobeying scripture.


Because of the current disarray in the UMC, some congregations are considering the possibility of disaffiliating from the denomination. This is the process to which the Administrative Council of Northwest Hills UMC now calls you to consider.


During this time of discernment, we will offer a series of informational meetings, as well as three listening sessions at which our District Superintendent will preside. At the end of this 6-month period, we will invite all full professing members to vote, by secret ballot, to decide if our congregation should disaffiliate from the United Methodist denomination.


Please watch for future information coming your way. Please pray for us to identify and follow God’s will in this matter.



Joe Baumgartner                                                        J. David Trawick

Chair, Administrative Council                                   Senior Pastor


Topics for the Disaffiliation Information Sessions

SESSION 1: A brief United Methodist history and how we got here

SESSION 2: Biblical study of “the hot button issue”

SESSION 3: Scripture: divinely inspired, dependable, authoritative?

SESSION 4: Is it just about sexuality?

SESSION 5: What will they think if we separate? if we do not? 

This is a video that Pastor Trawick recorded in May 2021 that gives you some information about the controversies in the UMC.

Before You Pull that Thread...